DUI Law Blog : DUI Lawyer & Attorney : Drunk Driving Defense & DWI News : Dan Jaffe

• Email This
• Print
• Comments
• Trackbacks
• Share Link

On April 23, 2009, the Court of Appeals of Georgia issued a new DUI opinion regarding the interpretation and application of Georgia's new implied consent law.

The case is Williams v. State of Georgia, and no official citation is available at this time. The case hinges on Georgia's implied consent law.

ISSUE:

Shawn Williams was charged with vehicular homicide, reckless driving, driving while under the influence of a drug, following too closely, and serious injury by vehicle. He moved to suppress results of a blood test that police obtained from him without first informing him of his implied consent rights. [FN1] The trial court denied his motion, but certified the order for immediate review. We granted Williams' application for interlocutory review. For the reasons that follow, we reverse.

RULING:

The amendment at issue here, however, is different. It states that nothing in the implied consent law precludes the state from acquiring a defendant's voluntary consent to chemical testing, or admitting into evidence the results of that testing. The implied consent statute grants drivers the right to refuse to take a state-administered test, with one of the consequences of exercising that right being that evidence of such refusal is admissible at trial. Unlike the amendment at issue in the cases relied upon by the state, the amendment here eliminates the need to give the notice where an individual "voluntarily" agrees to testing. This amendment not only changes the substance of the implied consent warning, it does away with the requirement that the warning be given at all where an officer manages to otherwise lawfully obtain consent to testing. This is not merely a procedural or evidentiary change, but one eliminating a defendant's substantive right to refuse to submit to testing. Therefore, the trial court erred in applying the amendment retroactively and in denying Williams' motion to suppress.

For more about Georgia DUI Law, see also, Georgia DUI Penalties and Georgia DUI Process.